Here’s what I see as the advantages & disadvantages ofeach program:
Georgia’s MLA Program:
Advantages:
* Potential for Teaching Assistantships due to the large undergraduate program.
* Potential for professional contacts / recognition /recommendations within the academic LA community.
* Name recognition of the program within the LA community.
* Recognition/understanding of my degree – the MLA isthe ‘typical’ degree of faculty, and specifically mentioned in the advertised criteria.
* Intimacy / environment of the program. With a smaller graduate program and studio environment (15-20students/year) I’d (probably) get to know my fellow students and the faculty better.
* Community Design Studio – GA has a strong community design studio that works throughout Georgia. I’m very interested in working with communities, so this wouldbe valuable.
* Small town / intimate nature of Athens, GA. I grew up in a smaller town, and miss the atmosphere.
* Proximity to family – I’d be 2 hours from myfather, and (only) 14 hours from my mother & brother.
Disadvantages:
* Tends to duplicate my base education – I’d get deeper understanding of landscape architecture, but not add as much breadth.
* My fellow students would generally be seeking their first professional degree, and I might not learn as much from them.
* Adds value only in an academic setting, not aprofessional setting. A BLA + CLA + MLA doesn’t seem to add up to much more value than BLA + CLA in the professional realm.
* I’d have to move cross-country (I live in Portland now). Only a slight disadvantage – most of my stuff is still in northern VA, and I’d have to move it out here.
* Athens has less of a market for part-time LA workat a rate consistent with my experience.
PSU’s MURP Program:
Advantages:
* Broadens my background, giving me credentials as both a LA and planner.
* Increases my understanding of the policy side ofthe built environment.
* In-state tuition in Oregon. Granted, this is less significant, given the potential for assistantships.
* Will be able to work part-time at my existing jobat a professional pay rate.
* PSU has a strong internship program withconnections throughout the Portland area, which couldpotentially give me exposure to a wide variety ofprofessional environments.
Disadvantages:
* Strong reputation within the Pacific Northwest, but limited (?) in the rest of the country.
* Larger ‘cohort’ of classmates (35-40) and no studio class means I might not know my classmates as well.
* Farther from family means less/more expensive visits.
* MURP degree is not typical terminal degree for LA faculty.
* Larger city may be more expensive place to live.
How much value would the teaching experience (as a TA) give? How important is the recommendations of my facultytowards getting a job? I’m assuming that recommendations from faculty within the LA community might count more that from those from the (unknown)planning community. Does the diversity of the MURP degree ad much value?